Key Privacy Doctrine Needs Updating due to Technology
June 15, 2015 | Stanford UniversityEstimated reading time: 2 minutes
The nation's privacy law should change to better reflect the reality of today's technology, a Stanford law professor says.
Robert Weisberg, the Edwin E. Huddleson, Jr. Professor of Law at Stanford University, said that the so-called "third party" doctrine of the Fourth Amendment needs to be reformed – it holds that people who voluntarily give information to third parties are not protected by a reasonable expectation of privacy. The law allows the government to constitutionally obtain information from third parties without a warrant.
Back in the 1970s when the doctrine was established, it simply allowed police to question gang members, for example, without needing a warrant. Over time, however, the courts expanded the exception, allowing warrantless searches of telephone metadata and financial records at banks.
This past spring, Weisberg guided students in a policy practicum on issues regarding state access to user records held by communications companies. The Stanford News Service recently interviewed Weisberg, the co-director of the Stanford Criminal Justice Center, on the topic.
Why do we need changes in the "third party" privacy doctrine?
The U.S. Supreme Court has made a supreme mess of the issue of application of the Fourth Amendment to information held by so-called third parties (companies.) It once held that customers of banks have no protection for their bank records, and customers of telephone companies enjoy no protection, at least for the record of phone logs (as opposed to actual conversations.) The high court just flat-out said that you waive any protection when you sign up.
Now, no one is so sure about how all this applies to Internet service providers and social media companies. On top of this, we as a society are nervous even about phone numbers, given the dot-connecting ability of modern data mining.
What are the recommendations that you suggest for changing the law?
When all is said and done, it's going to be about warrants for third parties. But warrants are not panaceas, because we will have to decide the standard the warrant must meet – is it a probable cause of a crime, or some discernable national security concern, for example – and what criteria merit an exception?
Why is a warrant requirement important for this type of data?
Warrants alone won't solve the problem. We have a two-plus centuries tradition of not quite trusting the executive branch.
Should the law treat information as private even though others know about it?
It depends on what you mean by "know about it." There's probably a consensus that even if Google has access to your email, and of course can read it if it wants, we reasonably expect that it will not use it for purposes we do not approve of.
In the light of accelerating technology, what's the most efficient way to address these issues?
Congress will attempt a comprehensive scheme to cover all this, and we can only hope that it finds its better congressional self and writes laws that do not leave too much interpretation to the courts.
Suggested Items
The Right Approach: I Hear the Train A Comin'
04/25/2024 | Steve Williams -- Column: The Right ApproachTraining is often an afterthought in many organizations, and the longer a company has been in business, the more this seems to apply. Over the past couple of decades, it has been amazing to observe that the biggest offenders of this are the companies that overuse the sound bite, “Our most important assets are our people.” When you dig into the process and peel back the onion, their commitment to training is not commensurate with that statement.
Record Numbers of Exhibitors to Showcase Products and Services at EWPTE 2024
04/25/2024 | IPCWHMA/IPC announces that 215 exhibitors spanning over 50,000 nsf of exhibit space will introduce new product technologies, innovations and demonstrations of the electrical wire harness, wire, coil winding and cable processing industries’ newest advancements at Electrical Wire Processing Technology Expo (EWPTE) to be held at Baird Center May 14-16, 2024, in Milwaukee, Wis. This marks the largest number of exhibiting companies in the event’s history. More than 3,000 attendees are expected to attend this year’s event.
Fujitsu, METRON Collaborate to Drive ESG Success
04/24/2024 | JCN NewswireFujitsu Limited and METRON SAS, a French cleantech company specializing in energy management solutions for industrial decarbonization, today announced a strategic initiative to contribute to the realization of carbon neutrality in the manufacturing industry.
GlobalFoundries Commits to Achieving Net Zero Emissions and Carbon-Neutral Power by 2050
04/23/2024 | GlobalFoundriesGlobalFoundries (GF) is furthering its commitment to sustainable operations and fighting climate change with the announcement of two new long-term goals to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and 100% carbon-neutral power by 2050.
NEC Strengthens Commitment to Space Industry with Investment in Seraphim Space Venture Fund II
04/22/2024 | JCN NewswireNEC Corporation announced a strategic investment in "Seraphim Space Venture Fund II," a pioneering venture capital fund specializing in the space industry and operated by Seraphim Space, the most prolific investor globally in this domain.